- In 2004, Reilly sponsored a bill to ban crocodiles, citing them as "nefarious, untrustable creatures who eat my luggage".
- Also in 2004, Reilly sought to allow Westchester County to secede from New York State and the United States, effectively making it a country.
- In 2006, Reilly tried to ban the exclamation point. According to Grammar Committee minutes, he believed the exclamation point to be "too violent". His proposal involved replacing it with a smiley-face emoticon.
- In 2007, Reilly attempted to knight a constituent. This involved attacking the constituent with a sword.
From his history, it's clear that MMA could very well remain banned in New York State. Um, not.